Home / Productivity & AI Workflows / Thinking & Decisions

Structured Comparison to Decide Between Three Options

Helps you choose between three options: it first sets the criteria that really matter, then compares benefits, trade-offs, risks, cost, time, long-term effects and best and worst cases, and lists what to find out before deciding.

decision makingtrade-offscomparisonrisks
You are a strategist who specializes in decisions.

My options: [option A], [option B], [option C]. I have to pick one.

1. Start by defining the criteria that genuinely matter for this choice.
2. Compare the options against those criteria, covering:
   - benefits
   - trade-offs
   - risks
   - cost
   - time needed
   - long-term consequences
   - the best-case and the worst-case scenario
3. End by listing the extra information I should collect before I decide.
More in Thinking & Decisions
10 Questions, Then 3 Clear Options for Any SituationNewThinking & DecisionsAsks you 10 questions to understand what you are dealing with, then gives you 3 clear options, each with its pros, cons and next steps.
My situation, in brief: [describe what you are dealing with]

Task:
1. First ask me 10 questions so you understand my situation. Wait for my answers.
2. Then give me 3 clear options. For each one list the pros, the cons and the next steps.
Open page
A Completely Different Strategy If Your Approach FailsNewThinking & DecisionsProposes a radically different strategy to try for your goal in case your current approach does not work.
Goal: [goal]

Question: suppose my current approach fails. What entirely different strategy should I try instead?
Open page
Blueprint of a Successful Person's First 5 Years, Adapted to YouNewThinking & DecisionsMaps how a successful person of your choice reached success, focusing on the key strategic decisions of their first 5 years, their mindset, habits and networking, then turns it into a simple framework you can apply from where you stand now.
Person to study: [name of the successful person]
My current situation: [short description of where you are now]

Task:
1. Build a detailed blueprint of this person's path to success, concentrating on the key strategic decisions they took in their first 5 years.
2. Break down their mindset, their habits and their networking strategies.
3. Turn these principles into a simple, practical framework that shows how I can adapt them to my own path, starting from my current situation.
Open page
Break Down a Hard Problem into Causes, Options and a PlanNewThinking & DecisionsSeparates the symptoms of your problem from its possible root causes, flags the missing information, proposes several solutions with pros and cons ranked by practicality and likely effect, and ends with an action plan for the best one.
The problem I am facing: [your problem]

1. Help me tell the symptoms apart from the possible root causes.
2. Point out the information we do not have yet.
3. Propose several possible solutions and compare their pros and cons.
4. Rank them by how practical they are and how likely they are to work.
5. Finish by giving me a clear plan of action for the option that comes out strongest.
Open page
Brutally Honest Expert Review of Your WorkNewThinking & DecisionsReviews your idea, plan or work as a blunt expert in your field would, against top professional standards: what is strong, weak or missing, what could fail, what to change or cut and what to do next, with no empty praise.
You are an expert in [field] and you are brutally honest.

My [idea / plan / work]:
[paste it]

Judge it by the standards a top professional in this field would apply. Tell me:
- What works well
- What is weak
- What is missing
- What could fail
- What I should change
- What I should cut
- What my next step should be

Only praise something when there is a specific reason to.
Open page